Improving the overall bandwith of torque control in drivetrains by reducing torque ripple
In many applications, controlling the torque of a drivetrain is very important. The dynamics of the torque control, mainly limited by the current control, affect the achievable bandwidth of speed controllers and, as a result, have an impact on how fast/smooth trajectories can be followed. Besides obtaining a fast torque response, the quality (i.e. is it ripple-free or not) of the achieved torque is also important. Torque ripple is the periodic increase or decrease in output torque as a shaft rotates and is caused by, for example, the interaction between the current and the resulting counter-electromotive force in an electrical machine. However, torque ripple can also have an origin outside the electrical machine, caused by oscillating masses, system flexibilities, the discrete combustion times of an internal combustion engine (ICE), etc. Reducing torque ripple is an important objective for almost all drivetrain manufacturers as it affects lifetime, performance, cost (oversizing of components), user comfort and sound radiation.
There are many ways to reduce torque ripple.
In this blog, we apply the latter strategy to demonstrate how we can reduce the torque ripple of an existing drivetrain equipped with a permanent magnetic synchronous machine without further design changes.
To reduce torque ripple through optimised set points and control strategies of drivetrain components, we’ve developed a method with the following steps:
Based on these three steps, we calculate for a given operating point of the motor (torque and speed) what the current set point should be while the rotor shaft is rotating. However, as many industrial applications in which torque ripple is an issue are driven at high rotational speeds, these current set points tend to have high-frequency components. Moreover, the higher the speed, the higher the frequency and thus the higher the required bandwidth of the current control. That is why proportional integral (PI) controllers, which are typically used for current control, do not suffice in this application. To overcome this issue, we’ve developed and applied innovative solutions using resonant and iterative learning controllers.
In the following two examples, we demonstrate the effect on motor torque and overall dynamics. The examples and methodology are discussed in detail in the Heurisko webinar on torque ripple reduction:
The reduction in inherent torque ripple in the above-presented case amounts to circa 83%. A consequence of this reduction is that both the drivetrain and the structure or system supporting it are less excited by torque harmonics. This is shown in the example below, where a speed sweep in loaded condition (load torque of 50Nm) is performed on a test bench with 2 motors (back-to-back). Whereas without reduction techniques, the resonance reaches a peak torque amplitude of 23Nm, reduction techniques can limit this to 6Nm. In the figure below, R stands for resonant control while ILC stands for iterative learning control.
Flanders Make has developed this torque ripple reduction technique in collaboration with Siemens Industry Software and Dana. The industrial partners got on board to work on the shared technological challenge of torque ripple reduction based on low-level motor control.
We offer methods and tools to reduce torque ripple, both at component (i.e. motor) and system level. We have experience in modelling and testing electrical machines and in their implementation in the overall system.
Please don’t hesitate to contact us if you want more information on torque ripple reduction.
Florian Verbelen - Business Developer
The increasing complexity, uncertainty and speed of change within our competitive economic world requires new ways of working. Not only to survive as..
Today, the insights on the impact of the 4th industrial revolution are growing. Companies with a clear Industry 4.0 (implementation) strategy have..
Sign up for our newsletter and receive the most interesting articles about innovations in the manufacturing industry and updates about Flanders Make.